A few months back I made up some Limoncello, as well as some Orangecello, and I figured I would share the recipe with you guys. To the side here is a picture of all that is left.
A lot of recipes I found use vodka, I decided to use Everclear 191 instead and am quite happy with the results. A liter of Everclear is about $20 and it makes about 4 bottles of finished product, depending on how high of an alcohol content you want. Some states however do not allow Everclear to be sold, so if you are unable to get a hold of it I would recommend finding a recipe using vodka.
We peeled the skins off using a vegetable peeler, making sure not to get the pith, or the white layer. If your peel has to much pith you will get a bitter flavor. We peeled a total of 3 lemons and 3 oranges for our recipe. We soaked each set of peels in 250 ml, or about a forth of a bottle of Everclear, for about a week. The high proof of the Everclear really helps with extraction and we could notice the liquid changing color after only a few minutes.
Over the week, we shook the container to move the peels around, as they were piled up and some stuck out of the liquid for a few days. I don’t know how important this step is, but I’m a fidgety guy.
After a week, we made a simple syrup using two parts distilled water to 1 part sugar. I used distilled water for the same reason I used Everclear, we figured it would be the most neutral and interfere with the lemon and orange flavors the least. The simple syrup is made simply by cooking the sugar and water together. I used 4 cups of water and 2 cups of sugar, so I had extra simple syrup after it was added in. After letting the simple syrup cool for about a half hour, I added 500 ml, or about 2 cups of it to each bottle and let it sit with the peels for a few more days. This will make it about 25% to 30% alcohol, if you would like it a little lower just add more simple syrup.
After about 3 days, I poured the liquid out through a cheesecloth and funnel into a new bottle, chilled it and enjoyed that evening. Although the product is ready to go right away, we found after letting it sit in the fridge for a few days the alcohol and lemon flavors melded together more, and became smoother. Also we feel that lemons extract much better, and give a much richer flavor than the oranges. It could possibly be the type of oranges we used, but if I make it again I will be adding more oranges to the mix.